Changes for page Claims

Last modified by Andrei Stefan on 2022/04/04 12:14

From version Icon 9.2 Icon
edited by Andrei Stefan
on 2022/04/03 17:18
Change comment: There is no comment for this version
To version Icon 9.1 Icon
edited by Dongxu Lu
on 2022/03/30 13:04
Change comment: There is no comment for this version

Summary

Details

Icon Page properties
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,1 @@
1 -XWiki.AndreiStefan
1 +XWiki.dongxulu
Content
... ... @@ -1,44 +1,17 @@
1 -== Basic claims ==
2 -The following claims are based on the use cases.
1 +CL001: Patient remembers to do the task, Part of UC001: Daily todo list
2 +The main difficulty of people with dementia is remembering daily tasks, so the robot reminding the users to do their tasks can help them remember and the music can help reinforce the connection to the daily tasks.
3 3  
4 -CL001: The patient can associate music they hear with activities they need to do.
5 -Given enough practice, the patient should be able to make a connection between the music and the tasks.
4 +CL002: User is happy because they completed a task, Part of UC001: Daily todo list
5 +Even if they are reminded to do the task and do not remember on their own, the patients still feel the satisfaction of having accomplished the task themselves (since the robot only reminds them and does not help accomplish the task).
6 6  
7 -CL002: The user can tell if the robot knows they completed the task.
8 -It is good to include some confirmation from the robot, so that the patients know that the robot knows that they are donw with the task and is not stuck waiting for a reply.
7 +CL003: Patient is happy to interact with others, Part of UC002: Visit from the care giver or loved ones
8 +Most elderly (disregarding whether or not they suffer from dementia) are eager to interact with their family, care givers, and even with people in general [citation?]. Thus, besides the benefit of updating the todo list to suit their preferences, the users also get to interact with others.
9 9  
10 -CL003: It is easier to contact the caregiver.
11 -It is also possible to just include the caregiver's contact information when setting up the robot.
10 +CL004: Patient is eager to be reminded of the newly added tasks or hear the newly selected music, Part of UC002: Visit from the care giver or loved ones
11 +After having updated the todo list, the patients will be happy when they remember new tasks they would have otherwise forgotten about. Likewise, while changing the music associated might take some time to get used to, the users will be happier while listening to music they like more or music they feel like "fits" better with the task itself.
12 12  
13 -CL004: Customizable settings make it easier for the patient to remember the correct activity.
14 -By allowing the users to pick music that they like or that they feel fits well with an activity, it should be easier for them to remember the connection.
13 +CL006: Patient finishes the exercises and the robot can record the data. With this property, the robot can track the routine of patient and help the caregivers or doctors to analyze the changes of patient's cognitive condition, for example, if exercise is really helpful for patient to delay the dementia.
15 15  
16 -CL005: Seeing the robot move along when exercising motivates the patient to keep exercising.
17 -Having a partner to exercise with is a good motivator to keep exercising. Could also link with RQ008: The robot can detect movements, to correct the user on their posture.
18 -
19 -CL006: Data helps design better exercise routines.
20 -By keeping track of exercise sessions and the patient's status during them, it is possible to optimize the workout program and fit it better to the user.
21 -
22 -CL007: Analysis can point out other health issues, if any.
23 -By looking at physical activity data over time, it is possible to spot patterns which point to physical ailments.
24 -
25 -CL008: It is possible to detect unresponsive patients.
26 -Movement is an essential part of interacting, so if the robot is able to detect the lack of movement mid conversation, it can deduce that the patient is unresponsive.
27 -
28 -== General claims ==
29 -CL011: Patient's health improves.
30 -
31 -CL012: Patient is happy to interact with the robot.
32 -
33 -== Tested claims ==
34 -The following claims are derived based on the basic ones for the quiz use case, and are the ones targeted in the evaluation.
35 -
36 -CL101: People with dementia remember their tasks easier if they are associated with a piece of music.
37 -The main objective of the robot is to make and reinforce the connection between music and task, so that the reminders would be gentler, in the form of a music fragment, rathern that directly reminding the patients wath to do.
38 -
39 -CL102: By practicing with the NAO, the connection between activity and music gets stronger over time.
40 -
41 -
42 42  **TODO:**
43 43  Can have analysis on the pros and cons that may happen with each stakeholder
44 44  Maybe change claims into these? Need more