Scenario 2: Decision Support

Version 23.1 by Dongxu Lu on 2023/01/13 02:01

Step 1: Use Case

Use case 2.1: Early Detection and Advice

TopicQuestionAnswer

image-20220610113727-1.png

Stakeholders

What users/stakeholders are involved in your use case?

(if there are many, choose 3 max to focus on)

Please add name, age, gender, and one hobby

(i.e. a first step towards the identification of personas).

Child

Teacher

Parent

Health care professional

...

image-20220610113727-2.png

Stakeholders' goal

What do these people want to achieve?

G2.1.1 Decision is made by teacher (and stakeholders) on need of support in child, based on automated wellbeing-data-driven advice

image-20220610113727-3.png

Values and motivation

Why do these people want to achieve this?

  • What are main drivers?
  • Which values are relevant (e.g., fairness, equality, autonomy, …)?

 

image-20220610113727-4.png

Role, task and context

What is humans' role in the overall task performance or activities? (e.g., think about the responsibilities)

What are the main tasks or activities of these people?

(Note that the roles, tasks or activities of the humans can change due to the introduction of new technology)

Which context factors have a major effect on the performance or activities?

 

Use case 2.2: Goal Setting

TopicQuestionAnswer

image-20220610113727-1.png

Stakeholders

What users/stakeholders are involved in your use case?

(if there are many, choose 3 max to focus on)

Please add name, age, gender, and one hobby

(i.e. a first step towards the identification of personas).

Child

Teacher

Parent

Health care professional

...

image-20220610113727-2.png

Stakeholders' goal

What do these people want to achieve?

G2.2.1 Goals are jointly set (teacher, parents, child) for child on wellbeing and support

image-20220610113727-3.png

Values and motivation

Why do these people want to achieve this?

  • What are main drivers?
  • Which values are relevant (e.g., fairness, equality, autonomy, …)?

 

image-20220610113727-4.png

Role, task and context

What is humans' role in the overall task performance or activities? (e.g., think about the responsibilities)

What are the main tasks or activities of these people?

(Note that the roles, tasks or activities of the humans can change due to the introduction of new technology)

Which context factors have a major effect on the performance or activities?

 

Step 2: Functions

TopicQuestionAnswer

image-20220610120005-1.png

Overall objective

What is the overall objective of the human-AI system?

How do the human and AI collaborate and support each other (interdependence)?

 

image-20220610120005-3.png

Functions

 

What are the functions of the AI-system(s)?

What does it actually do?

What are its inputs, what are its outputs?

R.2.1 ePartners4All shall request data relevant for decision-making

R.2.2 ePartners shall process data according to model (e.g., if-ten rules/cut off values)

R.2.3 ePartners4All shall provide advice based on data and model (e.g., child has good wellbeing, child could profit from support for development of relevant knowledge/skills (e.g., language, emotional development, healthy sleep)

R2.4 ePartners4All provides schema to set personal goals for child, related to support need (output UC 2.1)

R2.5 ePartners4All provides tasks/interventions to aid achieving personal goals

R2.5 ePartners provides overview of goals, tasks/interventions selected (i.e., input for UC 4.1 monitoring)

 

G2.1.1 Decision is made by teacher (and stakeholders) on need of support in child, based on automated wellbeing-data-driven advice  
G2.2.1 Goals are jointly set (teacher, parents, child) for child on wellbeing and support  

image-20220610120005-4.png

Interaction

How do you expect the human to interact with these AI-functions? Does the human provide any input? (just a (high-level) description of interaction(s) is fine, e.g. “Actor A provides feedback in the form of tags”)

 

Step 3: Effects

TopicQuestionAnswer

image-20220610120128-1.png

Positive consequences

Which positive effects are expected from the AI-functions

- to the performance of the actors who work with the AI (e.g., accuracy, speed, ...)?

- to the state of them (e.g., stress, understanding, trust, ...)?

 

 

image-20220610120128-2.png

Negative consequences

Do you foresee potential negative effects of the AI-functions:

- on the performance, state and/or values of the actors?

- on more general ethical or societal aspects?

What are they?

 

image-20220610120128-3.png

Impact on use-case

What is the impact of the AI-functions on the overall use case?

What does it add to the use case/how does it improve the use case as a whole?

 

Step 4: Claims

TopicQuestionAnswer

image-20220610120216-1.png

Measurements

For each positive and negative effect listed in step 3 , describe how you could evaluate (measure) whether they actually occur. 

image-20220610120216-2.png

Benchmark

For each measurement, what are the benchmarks (criteria)? (i.e., what are desired values?) 

image-20220610120216-3.png

Demonstration of AI-functionality

Can you describe how you could demonstrate that your AI-function(s) achieve(s) the effects that you listed in the previous question? 

Storyboard

[place a photo of your storyboards/Design Patterns here]