Skip to Content

Changes for page b. Test

Last modified by Demi Tao on 2023/04/10 10:13
From version 11.1
edited by Karthik Prakash
on 2023/04/07 20:06
Change comment: There is no comment for this version
To version 16.1
edited by Demi Tao
on 2023/04/08 01:06
Change comment: There is no comment for this version

Summary

Details

Page properties
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,1 @@
1 -XWiki.KarthikPrakash
1 +XWiki.DemiTao
Content
... ... @@ -93,7 +93,9 @@
93 93  
94 94  = 3. Results =
95 95  
96 -|=(% style="width: 199px;" %)Tasks|=(% style="width: 147px;" %)Succeded by Themselves|=(% style="width: 146px;" %)Succeded with Some Guidance|=(% style="width: 185px;" %)Succeded with Detailed Explicit Instructions|=(% style="width: 175px;" %)Average Time to Complete Task (s)
96 +=== Results of interaction: ===
97 +
98 +|=(% style="width: 199px;" %)Tasks|=(% style="width: 147px;" %)Succeeded by Themselves|=(% style="width: 146px;" %)Succeeded with Some Guidance|=(% style="width: 185px;" %)Succeeded with Detailed Explicit Instructions|=(% style="width: 175px;" %)Average Time to Complete Task (s)
97 97  |(% style="width:199px" %)Add a reminder|(% style="width:147px" %)14.29%|(% style="width:146px" %)28.57%|(% style="width:185px" %)57.14%|(% style="width:175px" %)75
98 98  |(% style="width:199px" %)Check weekly remainders on the Calendar page|(% style="width:147px" %)100%|(% style="width:146px" %)0%|(% style="width:185px" %)0%|(% style="width:175px" %)10
99 99  |(% style="width:199px" %)Create a personal profile|(% style="width:147px" %)7.14%|(% style="width:146px" %)50%|(% style="width:185px" %)42.86%|(% style="width:175px" %)43
... ... @@ -100,13 +100,40 @@
100 100  |(% style="width:199px" %)Verify current profiles|(% style="width:147px" %)85.71%|(% style="width:146px" %)14.29%|(% style="width:185px" %)0%|(% style="width:175px" %)10
101 101  |(% style="width:199px" %)Play memory game|(% style="width:147px" %)0%|(% style="width:146px" %)42.86%|(% style="width:185px" %)57.14%|(% style="width:175px" %)200
102 102  
103 -if possible, note down some Parts Where Users Struggled in each task.
105 +|(% style="width:330px" %)**Tasks**|(% style="width:523px" %)**Parts where people struggled**
106 +|(% style="width:330px" %)Add a reminder|(% style="width:523px" %)(((
107 +* Don't know where to start
108 +* No immediate audio feedback indicating success
109 +)))
110 +|(% style="width:330px" %)Create a personal profile|(% style="width:523px" %)(((
111 +* It's hard to type with taped fingers
112 +)))
113 +|(% style="width:330px" %)Play memory game|(% style="width:523px" %)(((
114 +* Have not idea how to play the game, sometimes even after listening to the explicit instructions
115 +* There are too many words in the text
116 +* The beta version has no right or wrong prompts, different from the instructions, making people confused
117 +)))
104 104  
119 +=== Results of survey: ===
120 +
121 +[[image:attach:chart.png||alt="Survey Results"]]
122 +
123 +=== Significance test: ===
124 +
125 +|**Attributes**|**P-value**
126 +|Accessibility|0,0644
127 +|Trustability|0,3165
128 +|Perceivability|0,4112
129 +|Understandability|0,1151
130 +|Empowerment|0,0895
131 +|Usability|0,0903
132 +
133 +
105 105  = 4. Discussion =
106 106  
107 -=== Limitations: ===
136 +=== Limitations: ===
108 108  
109 -We ran into some hiccups while creating the application and performing the experiment:
138 +We ran into some problems while creating the application and performing the experiment:
110 110  
111 111  ==== Implementation: ====
112 112  
... ... @@ -113,14 +113,27 @@
113 113  * We could not adapt the robot to the PwD due to time constraints. This means that we did not take into account the severity of the PwD's visual, acoustic and kinesthetic limitations while setting up Pepper.
114 114  * We could not test the full capabilities of the robot due to privacy constraints. Since we fabricated the information about relatives to protect the privacy of participants, we were not able to perform the scenarios in a realistic manner.
115 115  * Since the version of the Google Chrome browser on the Pepper tablet was outdated, we were not able to load our Flutter application onto it and simulate actual scenarios.
145 +* Participants where from a wide variety of different background and mother tongues, it was therefore not possible to adjust Pepper to the specific culture of the participant.
116 116  
117 117  ==== Evaluation: ====
118 118  
119 -* The participants who took part in our experiment were not affected by dementia.
149 +* It is important to note that the participants who took part in our experiment were not affected by dementia.
120 120  * The experiment was not conducted in a real-world setting.
121 121  * We were not able to test the improvement in memory recall since it involves sustained interactions with a particular user over time and our experiment involved brief, one-time interactions.
122 122  
153 +=== Future Improvements: ===
123 123  
155 +* We can make our system more realistic/adapted to PwD by incorporating human-like responses, gestures and movements to Pepper.
156 +* We can make our system fully gesture/voice controlled to enable the PwD to (% style="color:#000000; font-family:Arial; font-size:11pt; font-style:normal; font-variant:normal; font-weight:400; text-decoration:none; white-space:pre-wrap" %)use the system without assistance from a caregiver, increasing their autonomy.
157 +* (% style="color:#000000; font-family:Arial; font-size:11pt; font-style:normal; font-variant:normal; font-weight:400; text-decoration:none; white-space:pre-wrap" %)We can incorporate privacy protocols like voice authentication and gaze detection to ensure that all personal information about the PwD, relatives and caregivers are kept safe and confidential.
124 124  
125 -
126 126  = 5. Conclusions =
160 +
161 +After performing the experiment and running various statistical tests on the results obtained, we have made the following conclusions that hopefully answer some of our research questions:
162 +
163 +1. We believe that an information support application **DOES IMPROVE** a PwD's well-being, since it can (% style="color:#000000; font-family:Arial; font-size:11pt; font-style:normal; font-variant:normal; font-weight:400; text-decoration:none; white-space:pre-wrap" %)provide them with access to important information and support, improving their overall quality of life.
164 +1. We believe that a robot assistant **DOES IMPROVE** the experience of a PwD using it. The robot(% style="color:#000000; font-family:Arial; font-size:11pt; font-style:normal; font-variant:normal; font-weight:400; text-decoration:none; white-space:pre-wrap" %) can provide companionship and assistance, making them feel independent and less isolated.
165 +
166 +(% style="color:#000000; font-family:Arial; font-size:11pt; font-style:normal; font-variant:normal; font-weight:400; text-decoration:none; white-space:pre-wrap" %)While our experiment had its limitations, we believe that it provides a foundation for future research in developing personalized memory robots for people with dementia. We also believe that our research is applicable to mobile agents which increases the accessibility of the solution.
167 +
168 +
chart.png
Author
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +XWiki.KarthikPrakash
Size
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +15.4 KB
Content